John McCain in Munich last February:
Georgia and Ukraine have expressed their desire for a NATO Membership Action Plan. We should offer it to them at the summit. These two nations have every right to aspire to democracy and security as other states closer to the heart of Europe. Ukraine and Georgia have difficult neighbors and domestic challenges; they are young democracies and their road ahead will be difficult. But they should know that we will support them every step of the way, and we can show them this by supporting their aspirations at Bucharest.
So if Georgia was a NATO member, would they have refrained from getting into a shooting war with Russia? Would Russia have refrained from showing who’s military boss in the Caucuses? And if the answers to those questions are (as seems likely) no, would we now be compelled by the NATO treaty to either provide military support for Georgia against Russia, or else show that NATO membership doesn’t mean a whole lot?
Was McCain really all that clever and diplomatically savvy by suggesting that we ought to admit a country that already had military and territorial disputes with neighboring Russia into the NATO alliance, with no sign of being willing to back down?
Not that Russia doesn’t deserve some diplomatic slaps, but getting into a military defense alliance with Georgia is hardly like signing on to protect West Germany. Or Poland.
To be fair, Obama seems to think they should be in NATO, too.
I am glad that the sane Europeans nixed this back when it happened, the UK press was full of talk about how bringing Georgia into NATO meant that a hot war with Russia was not far off, but that is what the NEO-cons want, so I am glad that it did not happen.
And now that European fears of Georgia starting a war with Russia has played out, I doubt that Obama or McCain will be able to get them to change their minds.