Since I looked at books, how about movies (since I record my movie-watching over at Letterboxd)?
I watched 40 movies in 2017 — 12 new ones, the remainders ones I’d watched before.
Looking at the 4.5 and 5 stars out of five, of the 9 movies I rated that way all but one was a rewatch (the exception was the chilling HBO WW2 film Conspiracy). It looks like I tend to be harder on first views than in rewatches (I even bumped Wonder Woman up a half-point on rewatch).
Overall, a good year in movies. Looking forward to the next!