
Bp. Rob O’Neill has finally outlined the charges against outlined the charges against Rev. Don ArmstrongRev. Don Armstrong — whose parish declared it was quitting the Episcopal Church, joining the Church of Nigeria, and reinstating Armstrong on the same day (coincidentally, no doubt) the diocese’s Standing Committee (hardly a liberal institution) unanimously filed a Presentment (ecclesiastical indictment) against him. The specific charges (in the bishop’s letter to the parish):
In the case of the allegations made against Father Armstrong, the Presentment identifies the following canonical offenses: crime, immorality, violation of the Constitution or Canons of the General Convention, violation of the Constitution or Canons of the Diocese, violation of ordination vows, and conduct unbecoming a member of the clergy. The most pertinent detials of the offenses alleged to have been committed over an approximate ten-year period and documented in the Church Attorney’s report include:
- Theft from Grace Church of $392,409.93 in unauthorized payments for educational and personal expenses for Father Armstrong’s family.
- Tax Fraud involving $548,097.27 in non-salary income and benefits not reported to the Internal Revenue Service and Colorado Department of Revenue.
- The unlawful extension and receipt of loans to Father Armstrong totaling $122,479.16.
- The improper use of Clergy Discretionary Funds in the amount of $136,354.78.
- The unauthorized encumbrance and alienation of the parish’s real property.
- The failure to maintain proper books of accounts by causing Grace Church to record false or fraudulent entries in its books and records.
Yeah, but at least he’s got the right idea about keeping gays in their place, by God!
Given that Armstrong has basically decided he’s no longer under Episcopal authority, it’s unlikely he’ll face any specific judicial action by the diocese, unless it’s to formally remove him from his office. But I’ve little doubt that the respective tax authorities, and possibly the civil ones, will be sent copies of the pertinent documentation for their further action.
The comments to the Gazette article are kind of interesting to read. Including the observation that the local DA is (was) on the vestry of the parish …
Armstrong — in the brief period between going “Neener-neener, Rob O’Neill doesn’t control me,” and the formal accusations being described, tried to pass them off as overblown and weak here (at the bottom), largely as “I did it all virtuously, and, besides, everyone does that.”
While there are serious questions as to who is “in charge” of the parish building and the like, one would hope that nobody involved will unduly disrupt services for Palm Sunday, the upcoming Holy Week, or Easter. After that, fur will (and should) fly. (The diocese does not plan to confront Armstrong onsite)
More worthwhile commentary (and refutation of the “Ooooh, see the Evil Bishop Terrorizing the Poor Faithful Priest” meme (see comments) here. More news coverage here.
(via the Daily Episcopalian)
And, as a side note, the “Timeline” offered by Jean Torkelson at the Rocky is … kind of bizarre [my commentary]:
• 2003: Episcopal Church votes at national convention to allow openly gay bishops and same-sex blessings. Colorado’s bishop, Jerry Winterrowd, votes yes. [The Bishops confirmed the duly elected (by the clergy and laity) bishop of New Hampshire. It made no general statement about “openly” (vs covertly) “gay bishops.” The GC did not authorize same-sex blessings or liturgy, but acknowledged that various localities and dioceses were doing so, and declined to order them to stop.]
• 2004: New Bishop Rob O’Neill voices support for gay rights in the church. [He also refuses to act unilaterally, authorize such liturgy in the diocese, and seeks to engage the entire diocese in dialog over the issue until a consensus can be reached.]
• 2005: Worldwide Anglican report chides American church for rush to expand gay rights. [“Chide” and “rush” — nicely neutral language there, Jean. The Windsor report did conclude that the TEC should apologize for torquing off the Communion, should refrain from doing so in the future — and that foreign bishops should stop meddling in Episcopal territory. Guess which conclusions those foreign bishops choose to quote at length and which they ignore.]
• Feburary: Majority of primates governing the worldwide Anglican Communion call on the American church to step back from its gay rights position. [Actually, there is no “governing” here, only a mutual communion. And the majority of Primates, maneuvered by conservative forces at the meeting, also suggested that dissenting dioceses should get to have their own alternate primate, ostensibly authorized by the Presiding Biship of the Episcopal Church, but really under the direction of the primates. And, of course, they told the Episcopal Bishops that they had until September 30 to comply, ignoring that TEC is actually controlled by not just the bishops, but by laity and clergy.]
• March: American House of Bishops rejects the primates’ plea [demand, ultimatum] but affirms its desire to stay in the Anglican Communion. [Actually, they rejected the Primates’ suggestion that they could act unilaterally without consultation of the laity and non-bishop clergy. They refused to violate the constitution of TEC handing over authority over dissenting parishes and dioceses to, essentially, foreign control.] On Monday Grace and St. Stephen’s vestry votes to leave The Episcopal Church. [Okay, that’s fairly accurate.]
Fr. Jake notes that Rev. Armstrong — in between character assassination and ad hominem attacks at Bp. Rob and the Episcopal Church — has responded to the charges.
I guess that’s his rationale as to why the diocesan Standing Committee — which has quite a number of recognized conservative voices in it — voted unanimously for the Presentment. Because given some of the language from Rev. Armstrong in the past about the bishop, the fact that it’s taken this long for him to move against Armstrong smacks of anything but a fantasy-driven “fierce determination.”
He also writes here:
“Because we forced them into acting against us, we’ve proven they were planning on acting against us. So don’t blame us for dragging you into this crisis.” Right.